LATEST BORDERS RUGBY NEWS
brought to you by Border Insurance Services

Click to visit sponsor

Jan 30th
Only two local teams were able to play some rugby today due to the frost. In East League 1 Duns lost at Broughton 29-17 while in East League 2 Walkerburn suffered a narrow defeat at Inverleith 20-18. For Duns it gave them their 400th point of the season while Walkerburn's losing bonus point takes them level with St Boswells on league points for the season.

On Tuesday night there will be three matches played. Peebles will take on Stirling County at The Gytes in Premier 2 with an 8pm kick off following today's postponement while two fixtures in Pool A of the Border League have been re-scheduled. Langholm will host Kelso at Milntown while Hawick will play Jedforest at Mansfield Park - a game which will see the winners lift the annual Skelly Cup trophy. Both Border League matches will start at 7.30pm. Incidentally Calum Brown is back coaching at Jedforest - he will look after the forwards to the end of the season, assisting Head Coach Darren Cunningham.

Two of next Saturday's Cup games have been postponed due to the fact that Melrose and Currie have players playing in Friday's Scotland Club International fixture at Netherdale on Friday night against France. This means that Peebles v Melrose and Currie v Hawick will be re-arranged. The Currie game has already been re-scheduled for Saturday 13th February. Meanwhile Peebles will play at Biggar in a re-arranged Premier Division 2 clash.

Jan 29th
Bill McLaren will be remembered with a special event celebrating his wonderful life at Murrayfield Stadium on Thursday 11th March at 6.30pm. Two days before the Calcutta Cup game against England the event will be put together by the BBC, Scottish Rugby and the family of Bill McLaren. The big screens at the stadium will replay some of Bill's best moments and will give everyone a chance to pay their respects to the "Voice of Rugby" who died in his hometown of Hawick last week at the age of 86.  More details will be available soon with regards the event.

Jan 26th
Twelve teams are to compete at this year's Davidson Chalmers Melrose 7s Veterans Tournament. Taking part this year will be an invitation side from the Cayman Islands. The event will take place on Friday 9th and Saturday 10th April. The two local teams are Melrose and Alnwick. The Vets tournament, which is now in its third year, will consist of teams with 10 players and if any side is knocked out in the first round they will go into Plate and Bowl competitions. Last year the main trophy was won by Border Reivers, with Morgan winning the Bowl and Ledbury the Plate.

Jan 25th
The world of rugby said goodbye today to Bill McLaren, CBE, MBE, OBE, who was buried in his home town of Hawick this morning. The Teviot Parish Church was packed with hundreds more mourners outside. So many rugby stars were there to pay their respects and afterwards the streets of Hawick were packed with people breaking out in spontaneous applause as the funeral procession passed them. The journey ended at Wellogate Cemetery where the great man was laid to rest.




Top: Bill McLaren's widow Bette arrives for the service
Below left: Members of Hawick RFC carry the coffin into the church
Below right: Two local people among the mourners outside

Mourners were given Hawick Balls - Bill's favourite sweets - on their way in from Bill's grandchildren including Scottish international Rory Lawson and Scotland A player Jim Thompson. It was a lovely touch. Members of Hawick's Rugby Team did their club proud as they carried the coffin in and out of the church. It will be a memory which they will take with them for the rest of their lives.

The service, conducted by Minister Neil Combe, was very well presented and produced, and another grandson, Gregor Lawson, made a remarkable speech packed with anecdotes sprinkled with humour. Ian Landles recited his poem which he wrote a few years ago dedicated to Bill McLaren and it was received warmly.

President of the SRU, Jim Stevenson, was there along with Scottish rugby internationals including Gregor Townsend, Andy Irvine, Gavin Hastings, Ian McLauchlan, Sandy Carmichael, Colin Deans, Jim Renwick, John Jeffrey, Chris Paterson, Mike Blair, Nathan Hines and Hugo Southwell. Scottish coach Andy Robinson and former coach Frank Hadden were present along with representatives from clubs in the Borders. Colleagues from the world of Television also attended including John Inverdale, Jill Douglas and Nigel Starmer-Smith.


Left: Leaving the church for the final time.  Right: Local people line the streets to applaud Bill McLaren on his final journey through his beloved Hawick.

Pictures: Rob Gray, DigitalPic

It was a very emotional occasion and the whole family, lead by Bill's widow Bette, made a point of thanking everyone for their overwhelming tributes which have provided great comfort to them at this difficult time. Talking to people afterwards everyone felt that the service had captured exactly the right mood and while Bill would have probably had a chuckle to himself wondering what all the fuss was about, being a very private man, he would no doubt have been very chuffed that in his long lifetime he had managed to touch so many people. Watch our tribute video here.
Stuart Cameron

Jan 24th
Five local players are in the Scotland Club International squad for the game against France at Netherdale on Friday 5th February. The four from Melrose include captain John Dalziel, Scott Wight, James King and Callum Anderson, while Selkirk's Fraser Harkness has also been included. The match is free to attend and kicks off at 7.30pm. Selkirk's Lee Jones has been selected to represent Scotland Sevens squad for the next two IRB World Sevens tournaments in Wellington, New Zealand, and Las Vegas, USA.

Jan 23rd
Melrose and Selkirk were both on the road today in Premier 1 but only Selkirk came back with any points - a try bonus for crossing the line four times at Burnbrae in their game against West Of Scotland. West scored five to beat them 34-25. The result drops Selkirk down to eighth in the table with 34 points and are nine points ahead of Watsonians (who won at home against Dundee HSFP today) and currently fill the second relegation spot with Stewart's Melville a further 12 points adrift. Selkirk's tries came from Fraser Harkness, Martin Murray, Dan Moussa and Scott Hendrie with Hendrie also kicking a penalty and conversion.


Left: Fraser Harkness on the run.  Right: Martin Murray rounding an opponent

Pictures: Grant Kinghorn, GrantKinghornpics

Melrose went down to Heriot's at Goldenacre by 28-16 with their only try coming from a consolation effort from hooker Wayne Mitchell who typically burrowed his way over in injury time. Scott Wight scored all Melrose's points up till then and converted Mitchell's try.

Into Premier 2 and good news for Hawick as they beat Biggar 23-9 at Mansfield Park, keeping them at the top of the table and also putting them three points clear of Melrose in the Borders Rugby Rankings table. John Coutts and Bruce McNeil both scored tries to give them 10 each for the season and put them joint second behind Fraser Thomson (Melrose) who is on 13.  Graham Hogg kicked both conversions and two penalties while Coutts also dropped a goal. 




Top: A poignant moment as players from both Hawick's and Hawick YM's games remember the late Bill McLaren with a minute's applause at Mansfield Park. 
Right: Neil Renwick back after injury on the attack against Biggar.

Top and Right Pictures: Rob Gray, DigitalPic

Left: Bruce McNeill, now up to 10 tries for the season, in action against Biggar.
Left Picture: Kenny Baillie, Hawick RFC

In the border derby Kelso were too good for Gala winning 28-7 at Poynder Park. They scored three tries from Kevin Utterson with a brace and MeeKaaEel Hartley, with Greg Pontin on form with the boot, landing 2 conversions and three penalties.  Gala's points came from an Ian Ross try converted by Gregor Hunter.  Kelso now jump above Jedforest into 10th place as Jed lost 31-9 on the road to Stirling County, with Ewan Scott's three penalties the only reward for their day's work. 

Peebles won at bogie side Haddington's ground, Nielsen Park, for the first time in many years as they ran up a 22-0 score. Dale Clancy was back after two years out through injury and celebrated with a try while Neil Hogarth and Ryan McConnell also crossed for a try each. Donald Anderson kicked 2 conversions and a penalty.

In the crucial battle in the mud at Scremerston in National League 1, it went the way of the visitors as Langholm beat Berwick 21-10. It wasn't a pretty game by any means but the result puts Langholm eight points clear of Berwick in the table. The men from Milntown stay 10th but they've opened up daylight between them and their Border rivals with Annan almost certain of going down in last place.

With just six games to play it's beginning to look desperate for Berwick who must start winning. Langholm raced to a 10-0 lead with a Jamie Little try superbly converted from the touchline by Colin Jardine who also kicked a penalty from the same position. Berwick responded with a Jack Webster penalty before the interval and fought back to score a try when Richard Hume went over the line shunted forward by his pack who took full advantage when Cammy Little was yellow carded earlier.

Jardine's excellent kicking display from the first period wasn't repeated in the second half when he missed four, but he did manage to succeed with a penalty to put his team 16-10 up. Berwick refused to go for goal when awarded a penalty in front of the posts while still a man up and the scrum they chose instead came to nothing. Soon after another Little try converted by Jardine sealed the game for Langholm who must now be favourites to stay up but they still have work to do. You can watch highlights of the match here.

In National League 2 Hawick YM secured a winning bonus point thanks to a 33-24 win over Waysiders Drumpelier and that result should take away any relegation worries they may have for this season. They scored five tries through Shaun Desport, who got two, and one each by Ryan Halliday, Steve Anderson and Hamish Neish. Gregor Welsh kicked four conversions. Three red cards were brandished in this game, two of them going to YM players David Douglas and Keith Traynor.

With Hawick and Hawick YM both winning at home, Hawick Linden were hoping to make it a hat-trick of home wins for the town on the first day of rugby following the death of Hawick's favourite son Bill McLaren, and they did it too with a well earned 18-10 win over Hillfoots, Barry Sutherland kicking six penalty goals to secure the victory and ease the club's own relegation fears for at least another week in their first season in National League 2. This result was particularly impressive when you consider the corresponding fixture away from home earlier in the season saw Linden beaten 42-0.

Moving to East League 1 and the only local team to win was Duns, who narrowly went past Lismore by a single point to take the game 14-13. Hawick Harlequins were no match for league leaders North Berwick on the road - they went down 43-14 - and Earlston found the going too tough at second placed Portobello, losing 26-5.

In East League 2 there was a thumping victory for Walkerburn who leathered bottom club Liberton 86-0 while St Boswells narrowly lost their home game against promotion candidates Leith 29-25. Gala YM's game against Queensferry was postponed.

Jan 20th
Before tonight Gala and Peebles had met twice this season in Premier 2 with each result going the way of the visiting team, and it happened again at Netherdale with Peebles taking the game 18-12 and in winning, also scored the only two tries of the game through James Oakes and Ryan McConnell. Steve Gee converted one of them and added two penalties while Gregor Hunter, with three, and Graham Speirs, who kicked one, scored penalties for the Maroons.

Both sides were understandably rusty not having played for well over a month, but there was plenty of passion and three yellow cards dished out to both Peebles' try scorers and Gala's Chris Weir. Peebles take the four points to tuck themselves in just behind Melrose, while Gala got a losing bonus point. Go to our Border League page for the latest news and tables from the Border League.

Jan 20th
Hawick Rugby Club have opened a book of condolence for people to make their comments with regards Bill McLaren's death this week. The book will be situated at the Scottish Borders Council Customer Services Office at the Hawick Town Hall, High Street from 10am to 4pm weekdays.

The funeral for Bill McLaren will take place at Teviot Church in Hawick on Monday. The service, conducted by the Reverend Neil Comb, begins at 9.30am and will be relayed on a PA system to crowds expected to gather outside the church. Internment will take place at Wellogate Cemetery in Hawick at 11am.  Click here for our tribute page.

Jan 19th
The death has been announced of William "Bill" Pollock McLaren CBE OBE MBE, one of the best loved broadcasters in history, and one of the most famous Borderers. Bill was 86 years old and known the world over as The voice of Rugby. His last commentary for the BBC was at the Melrose Sevens in 2002, but his final commentary for an international match was at the Millennium Stadium for the game between Wales and Scotland.

McLaren was born in Hawick on 16th October 1923. He grew up playing rugby and was a useful flank forward but his one regret was not quite making it to Scottish international status. "I would have given everything for just the one cap" he told me in his last ever radio interview. Sadly a serious illness prevented him from playing rugby but he turned his attention to reporting on the game of rugby and quickly rose to the very top of the tree.


Bill McLaren (1923 - 2010)

Bill was one of the nicest men you could hope to meet. He had time for everyone and touched many people who met him. The world has lost one of the true greats. His answer to the question "How would you like to be remembered?" was simply this: "I'd like to be remembered for being fair and treating everybody alike. I think if you've done that you've done pretty well."

Bill had been in poor health for a number of years. He is survived by his wife Bette.
Stuart Cameron

Jan 19th
In tonight's Border League Pool A game Jedforest went to the top of the table with a bonus point win at Langholm by 34-10. Their six tries were scored by Darren Gillespie, Scott Raeburn, Jonny Cunningham, Paul Pringle, David Gobby and Robert Ferguson with Ewan Scott kicking two conversions. Gavin Campbell scored both Langholm's tries.

Kelly Brown has signed for Saracens. Currently at Glasgow Warriors, the former Earlston High School pupil, Melrose RFC and Border Reivers player who is very much part of the Scotland squad, will head south for the start of next season.

Jan 16th
Some of our top players managed to get a game today as part of the Scotland U20 and Scotland Club International squads who got together at Dunbar for a run-out. The Club side won by 19-0 with local backs Callum Anderson and Fraser Harkness both crossing for tries.  Meanwhile a hastily re-arranged Border League fixture took place in Pool B also at Dunbar between Haddington and Melrose. Melrose went top with a bonus point win by 38-3. They scored six tries including a brace each for Richard Higgins and Craig Jackson and one each for Scott McCormick and Allan Dodds. Bruce Dick landed four conversions while Nick Bell scored Haddington's only points with a penalty.


Three of Melrose try scorers today L to R:
Allan Dodds, Richard Higgins, Craig Jackson

Hawick YM travelled to Greenock Wanderers - the only game in the Premiership or National Leagues involving local teams which survived the weather - but they lost to the league leaders 27-14. Mark Young and Bruce Campbell scored a try each with Gregor Welsh kicking two conversions.

In the other local game, a friendly between Berwick and Hawick played at Berwick High School, the Greens won 19-3 scoring three tries from Bruce McNeil, Lee Armstrong and Graham Hogg. John Coutts kicked a conversion, as did Neil Renwick on his return from injury.

Langholm will play Jedforest on Tuesday night at Milntown in another re-arranged game, kicking off at 7.30pm. Gala will play Netherdale on Wednesday at Netherdale.

Jan 15th
The Melrose game against Ayr in P1 is off but instead Melrose will play Haddington at Dunbar RFC in their re-arranged Border League fixture. There is a good chance that Hawick YM will be able to take on Greenock Wanderers on the road in National League 2 as reports coming out of Greenock are positive. But three local games in P2 are victims of the weather - Gala v Aberdeen Grammar, GHA v Hawick and Jedforest v Haddington.  The match between Peebles and Kelso in Premier 2 has been called off after a Friday night pitch inspection.

Berwick and Langholm's NL1 matches are off but Berwick have hurriedly arranged a friendly with Hawick at Scremerston, kicking off at 2pm. The first team pitch is unplayable so this game will take place on the training ground while a 2nd XV friendly between the two teams will take place at the local Berwick High School.

All matches in the East League involving local teams are also postponed.

Tomorrow a number of Borderers will be taking part at Dunbar in a friendly game between Scotland U20 and Scotland's Club International side. Berwick and Newcastle's Aaron Hall will turn out for the U20 side along with Luke Pettie (Melrose) while the Club International line-up includes Melrose players Scott Wight, John Dalziel (who will again captain the team this season), Jamie Murray, James King, Callum Anderson and Fraser Thomson, and Selkirk's Fraser Harkness and Lee Jones, making his first appearance since getting injured in Dubai with the Scotland 7s squad.

Jan 14th
Local rugby matches look very doubtful for this Saturday despite the thaw. Pitches still have plenty of snow on them and are absolutely soaking wet. Gala's game against Aberdeen Grammar was the first to be called off. The undersoil heating is ineffective against extremely wet weather. Selkirk's game at home to Currie was always going to be doubtful. Groundsman Brian Cassidy said that it was extremely difficult for anyone to get near the ground let alone onto the pitch. Hawick's game at GHA was declared postponed earlier today while matches at Jedforest, Peebles and Melrose are likely to be scrapped this evening. But if anything goes ahead we will let you know about it so keep checking our home page for the latest news.

Jan 12th
The weather forecasters didn't predict the 3 degrees we had today causing a thaw and they have now changed their forecast from snow to sleet and rain for the rest of the week giving hope for some live rugby in the Borders this weekend. If the roads from Aberdeen are clear we may well see the Gala v Aberdeen Grammar game going ahead at Netherdale, which has the undersoil heating in any case. The very latest forecast from the Met Office shows temperatures just above freezing point for the rest of the week with the only risk of snow being on Saturday. However, fog will be prominent over the next few days which could give rise to different problems. Keep checking our latest weather updates and breaking news as the week progresses at our home page.

Jan 11th
The latest forecast for the next few days confirms that there's more snow on the way in the Scottish Borders with temperatures not getting much above freezing, which puts next weekend's rugby card in doubt. The league season is due to continue after the break with both Selkirk and Melrose scheduled to play at home. There is some hope that Gala will be able to use their undersoil heating at Netherdale but they're due to take on Aberdeen Grammar, and with a long trek in store for the Aberdonians in treacherous conditions they may decide that such a long trip would be a pointless and dangerous exercise. For the record, Monday and Tuesday should bring a mix of snow, sleet and rain with temperatures no more than Freezing point. Wednesday will bring further snow, Thursday and Friday will be cloudy as temperatures dip to minus 2 degrees with more snow forecast for Saturday - again with temperatures predicted at around zero degrees celsius.

Keep checking our home page at www.BordersRugby.net for the very latest news on games off. Meanwhile the next meeting of the Border League is scheduled for January 20th and top of the agenda will no doubt be the subject of the weather and indeed how the clubs intend tackling the Border League which has hardly got going with only two games played so far. Cancelling the rest of the matches for this season may be a sensible solution and one which would take the pressure off clubs and players. It would certainly be more difficult to slot in midweek games among the re-scheduled league fixtures - especially as the Final at Melrose is "set in stone" for April 14th. Also at that meeting it is expected that the South of Scotland team's future opponents will be up for discussion. Secretary of the Border League, John Thorburn, has confirmed that there has been interest from other teams who wish to play games against the resurrected district team.

Jan 10th
Rory Hutton, the former Hawick player who made his Magners League debut for Edinburgh tonight, was showered with compliments from the media for his fantastic display in which he showed everyone north of Soutra Hill what we all knew already in the Borders. There were dummies, jinks and tricks up his sleeve as he ran rings round many of the Cardiff Blues. His individual brilliance led to Edinburgh's first try for Ross Rennie and it was a joy to watch. He played a big part in the second try as well in which Jim Thompson crossed over to score. All this after a nervous opening in which he struggled to impress. The fact that nearly every daily newspaper which covers rugby is talking him up as a potential Scotland fly half speaks volumes for the 22 year old's impact on the professional game, and it was interesting that with Edinburgh's win at Murrayfield by 21-12 it meant Rory has never been beaten on the famous turf, having won there three times previously in the colours of Hawick Albion and Hawick Wanderers (twice) in the finals of the Youth Cup.

Jan 6th
All local rugby matches have been confirmed as postponed on Saturday.

Jan 5th
Former Hawick fly half Rory Hutton has been selected for Edinburgh for their Magners League game against Cardiff Blues on Saturday (6.30pm kick off) at Murrayfield which you can see live on Sky Channel 134 (S4C Channel). Rory is part of the National Academy now and has been out injured for most of the season. He now plays for Heriot's and was joined at the club by Graham Hogg, but Hogg recently returned to play for The Greens.


Rory Hutton Picture: Rob Gray, DigitalPic

The 22 year old did play for Edinburgh pre-season in a friendly against Newcastle Falcons but this will be his first game for Edinburgh on the big stage. Coach Rob Moffat said: "We are looking forward to seeing what Rory can do. He impressed us in pre-season and has been training with us recently. It is right that he gets his chance this week. This may be his Magners debut but he has a lot of experience of Premier 1 Rugby with Heriots and Hawick and as a member of the Scotland 7s squad."  Hutton's elevation to the first team is one of six changes from the side which lost both games against Glasgow Warriors. He replaces the rested Phil Godman and partners ex Jedforest scrum half Greig Laidlaw.

Jan 4th
The
weather forecasters have predicted heavy snow showers and temperatures down to as low as 12 Celsius for the whole of this week making it very unlikely that next week's local games will be played. For the very latest news on fixtures keep checking our fixtures list and Breaking News banner on our home page.

Jan 4th - Editorial by BRTV's Stuart Cameron

"With the inevitable call off of games due to bad weather it would seem a good idea to get at least two of the four Border League games played on a midweek in August or September when the pitches are good and there's plenty of light. That would leave just two games to be slotted in later in the season. It is common sense on many counts because Border League fixtures are the first to be kicked out of the schedule by the SRU who use those dates to re-schedule their league matches."
 

That is what I wrote this time last year when the Border League once again became a mess. As someone who cares about the oldest league in rugby I put forward a number of proposals to re-vamp the competition - all of which were thrown out unceremoniously, with the clubs opting for the status quo. I feared the worst and the worst has happened.  I once again appeal to all the clubs and the Border League to take action to save the competition for next season because as has been proved yet again you simply cannot rely on good weather in the winter. 

The most radical change proposed was actually by Ian Park of Langholm RFC which I totally endorsed. His idea was to have a two-tier league to ensure healthier competition with a "one-up, one down" promotion and relegation system to add spice to the event. I thought this was a great idea - particularly for the smaller clubs - but it was dumped.  

The most important thing though is to make sure that the tournament's credibility is kept intact and at the same time ensure that the general public know what is going on. Some clubs didn't have any information on their own websites about games on and off and that is a cause for concern. If clubs want people to support them they MUST look after their customers. This can be fixed at a stroke and needs to be addressed.  

So what has happened so far with this season's Border League? 

Of the first fourteen games in the fixture list for the Border League 12 have been postponed due to bad weather or because the SRU have taken priority on scheduled Border League dates and shifted league games there. Two games have been postponed because of player holidays or an existing traditional game on one of the dates.  That leaves just two games played - one in Pool A and one in Pool B.  No new dates have yet been assigned for the postponed games, and with the Final set to take place on April 14th there is now a monumental problem slotting in matches for the rest of the season, and the danger is that the Border League will become a low priority for clubs as they battle with more important promotion or relegation issues of the Premiership and National Leagues. 

One of my proposals last year was to double-head BL matches with Premier or National games to reduce fixture congestion.  This was also thrown out in favour of more rugby at a time when the likes of Roy Laidlaw, Director of Rugby at Jedforest, and others, are crying out for less.  The clubs' argument was that it meant more local derbies and more revenue. Of course in a climate where we don't get bad weather this is perfect. Sadly we don't and the net result of this decision is that even more matches than last year have piled up.  

To be frank we are in a bigger mess this year with the Border League than we were last, and there are now no easy solutions to the problem.  Many spectators have told me that there is nothing worse than trying to follow a chaotic competition which is constantly having its fixtures re-arranged or put on hold. Some have lost interest, and that is bad news. 

It is surely time for the Border League and all the clubs to seriously sit down and look at this ongoing problem yet again and meet these issues head on. There ARE solutions to the problems for next season onwards and I hope, for the sake of the Border League, that this will finally be done for next season. Changes need to be made. 

Once again I am putting forward my solution for next season based on the Pool system which the clubs appear to want.  Each team has to play four games, so play two of them midweek in late August and/or September when the pitches are in good condition and there's enough light for the two teams without floodlights (Melrose and Berwick) to play home games.  For the other two you simply double-head with a league game and there you have it. Even if the two league matches are postponed at least you know they will be played on a Saturday because the SRU will ensure those games will be fitted in to one of the standby dates. To me, unless I am missing something, this has to be the best way of sorting this problem. Speaking with Bob Hogarth, Director of Rugby at Peebles, he actually supported the idea of playing competitive rugby pre-season instead of friendlies so that Border teams would hit the ground running at the start of the official league season. 

If we do get a very mild winter (and pigs might fly) any spare dates available could easily be filled with friendly matches between Border teams. In short, it's easier to add dates to a fixture list than slot in dates into a packed calendar.  

So that's the proposal for next season. What about THIS season and the backlog of fixtures? The big problem is that the April 14th date for the final at The Greenyards is set in stone, so I am told. The only route to go down now is hurriedly arranged midweek fixtures which will put extra pressure on players and clubs, which is what happened last season. All at a time when crucial promotion and relegation issues are to be settled. I am still amazed the clubs voted for the status quo (and to make matters worse, additional fixtures instead of double headers) when the odds of this happening again were very short indeed. 

There is, however, another solution to the problem which is more controversial but actually a sensible option. Why not axe the Border League for this season? Instead of trying to get out of an almost impossible situation why not admit defeat and call it quits? It would take an immense amount of pressure off everyone and start afresh next season?  I would prefer that to be honest and it would be very interesting to see if the clubs considered it.   

Long term it's clear as I go round the clubs that one of the most talked about subjects in rugby is the Scottish Cup which is losing its appeal to Border clubs (perhaps with the exception of Melrose for obvious reasons). There is no prize money, plenty of travel costs and the prestige which used to be attached to it has largely disappeared. Even with the fact that the finals day is at Murrayfield, you cannot escape the fact that the competition is not what it used to be.  

In just 10 years 20,000 people have been lost from the gate and that is a massive amount. 24,000 attended in 1999 and last year 4,000 mostly from this area! There have been more than a few mutterings from players and officials that now is the right time to pull out of the National Cup and concentrate on local rugby. Maybe here is another opportunity to revamp the Border League using Cup days to play games and get it back to what it used to be with our Border teams playing each other rather than only three of them en route to the final? 

Sports journalist and author of The Border League Story, Laing Speirs, would take things further.

"The Border clubs have the chance at the moment, with the return of the South, to engage with the S.R.U. in a serious review of all fixtures throughout Scotland. A united voice from the Borders would surely not go unheard at a time when the Union is returning top class rugby to the Borders. A strong Border League and serious competition, in whatever form, and preferably involving double headers, would compensate for loss of separate fixtures."  

I have been so impressed with the way the Border League got behind Gary Parker and Richie Gray's initial suggestion of resurrecting the South team. Full marks to everyone involved including Hawick RFC who got things rolling. The result of this initiative has been 100% positive. Wouldn't it be fantastic if everyone here could finally sort out the Border League situation? I would fully support the idea of everyone getting round the table and looking positively at this. 

Finally, we are living in a world where money is tight and clubs are struggling to survive, particularly in the Borders. New initiatives need to be looked at to get people through the turnstiles. A comment on the Hawick RFC website triggered an idea. The scribe wrote that it would be good if, when two or three big local games are played on the same day, the kick off times were staggered to allow people to take in two matches on the same afternoon. The day they referred to was when Melrose were playing Selkirk at The Greenyards at 2pm and Gala were playing Hawick three miles down the road at 3pm. Had the kick off time at Melrose been moved to 1pm fans of Borders rugby would have easily been able to watch both. This is sensible and easy to arrange, so why not do this for the future? 

My own suggestion would be this. Why don't we introduce the Borders Rugby Season Ticket? The idea is that every club sells the pass for, say, £99 a season to its own members, and keeps the money to plough back into its own coffers? That would be a healthy cash injection at the start of a season, even if 100 were sold you would be talking about £10,000.  The pass would get you in to watch any league, cup or Border League game at any Border venue throughout the season encouraging people to watch club rugby even when your own local team is playing many miles away from home. If as a spectator you had a pass like this you would naturally want to get as much value out of it as you could and you would end up seeing plenty of local rugby throughout the season at any ground you like. By going to more games and not paying at the gate you'll still spend money at the ground and this surely is a win-win situation for all. 

And so endeth my annual lecture! Do let us know your own thoughts and potential solutions to these problems.

Jan 1st
The
Border League games between Kelso and Hawick and Haddington v Melrose have been postponed.

Dec 31st
The South of Scotland finally ran onto the pitch for the first time in 14 years at Netherdale last night and won the first leg of the QUBE (UK) Cross Border Challenge series against Northumberland by 37-3, effectively winning the game with a very good first half display, going in at the break 25-3 up. They scored five tries in all, with a brace each from Ross Miller and Fraser Harkness and one from John Coutts with Scott Wight kicking three conversions and two penalties.


The South's try scorers

The second half saw the visitors come right back into it, throwing the ball about and playing the more adventurous rugby, but they couldn't add to their penalty goal from the first half by Marcus Rutter. A larger than expected crowd, due to the freezing conditions, of well over 2000, played their part in making the occasion a special one for the area, although with both teams using all ten replacements, the game deteriorated towards the end as a spectacle. But it's first blood to the South and they should be able to defend their 34 point lead into the second leg next year when the return match takes place. Watch highlights and hear full match commentary here.


Left: Ross Miller on the ball for The South.  Right: The scoreboard tells the story.


Left: Scott Wight lifts the QUBE Trophy.  Right: The victorious South team.

Pictures: Rob Gray, DigitalPic

FOR NEWS ARCHIVE CLICK OUR NEWS BUTTON AT THE TOP
AND SCROLL TO THE BOTTOM OF OUR NEWS PAGE FOR LINKS